It was possible to get into a situation where successfulPieces =
es.RequiredCount(), errorCount < minFailures, and inProgress == 0 (when
the succeeding gets all completed before the failures), whereupon the
last goroutine in the limiter would sit and wait forever for another
goroutine to finish.
This change corrects the handling of that situation.
As an aside, this is really pretty confusing code and we should think
about redoing the whole function.
Change-Id: Ifa3d3ad92bc755e563fd06b2aa01ef6147075a69
This code is essentially replacement for eestream.CalcPieceSize. To call
eestream.CalcPieceSize we need eestream.RedundancyStrategy which is not
trivial to get as it requires infectious.FEC. For example infectious.FEC
creation is visible on GE loop observer CPU profile because we were
doing this for each segment in DB.
New method was added to storj.Redundancy and here we are just wiring it
with metabase Segment.
BenchmarkSegmentPieceSize
BenchmarkSegmentPieceSize/eestream.CalcPieceSize
BenchmarkSegmentPieceSize/eestream.CalcPieceSize-8 5822 189189 ns/op 9776 B/op 8 allocs/op
BenchmarkSegmentPieceSize/segment.PieceSize
BenchmarkSegmentPieceSize/segment.PieceSize-8 94721329 11.49 ns/op 0 B/op 0 allocs/op
Change-Id: I5a8b4237aedd1424c54ed0af448061a236b00295
Additional elements added:
* monkit metric for observers methods like Start/Fork/Join/Finish to
be able to check how much time those methods are taking
* few more logs e.g. entries with processed range
* segmentsProcessed metric to be able to check loop progress
Change-Id: I65dd51f7f5c4bdbb4014fbf04e5b6b10bdb035ec
Several tests using `(*ECRepairer).Get()` have begun to exhibit flaky
results. The tests are expecting to see failures in certain cases, but
the failures are not present. It appears that the cause of this is that,
sometimes, the fastest good nodes are able to satisfy the repairer
(providing RequiredCount pieces) before the repairer is able to identify
the problem scenario we have laid out.
In this commit, we add an argument to `(*ECRepairer).Get()` which
specifies how many failure results are expected. In normal/production
conditions, this parameter will be 0, meaning Get need not wait for
any errors and should only report those that arrived while waiting for
RequiredCount pieces (the existing behavior). But in these tests, we can
request that Get() wait for enough results to see the errors we are
expecting.
Refs: https://github.com/storj/storj/issues/5593
Change-Id: I2920edb6b5a344491786aab794d1be6372c07cf8
implemented observer and partial, created new structures to keep mon
metrics remain in same way as in segment loop
Change-Id: I209c126096c84b94d4717332e56238266f6cd004
The Reporter is responsible for processing results from auditing
operations, logging the results, disqualifying nodes that reached
the maximum reverification count, and passing the results on to
the reputation system.
In this commit, we extend the Reporter so that it knows how to process
the results of piecewise reverification audits.
We also change most reporter-related tests so that reverifications
happen as piecewise reverification audits, exercising the new code.
Note that piecewise reverification audits are not yet being done outside
of tests. In a later commit, we will switch from doing segmentwise
reverifications to piecewise reverifications, as part of the
audit-scaling effort.
Refs: https://github.com/storj/storj/issues/5230
Change-Id: I9438164ce1ea4d9a1790d18d0e1046a8eb04d8e9
Reputation updates during repair currently consumes a lot of database
resources. Sometimes increasing the rate of repair is more important
than auditing a node based on whether they have or don't have the
correct piece during repair. This is the job of the audit service.
This commit is to implement an intermediate solution from this issue: https://github.com/storj/storj/issues/5089
This commit does not address the more in-depth fix discussed here: https://github.com/storj/storj/issues/4939
Change-Id: I4163b18d78a96fadf5265789fd73c8aa8def0e9f
As part of the effort of splitting out the auditor workers to their own
process, we are transitioning the communication between the auditor
chore and the verification workers to a queue implemented in the
database, rather than the sequence of in-memory queues we used to use.
This logical database is safely partitionable from the rest of
satelliteDB.
Refs: https://github.com/storj/storj/issues/5251
Change-Id: I6cd31ac5265423271fbafe6127a86172c5cb53dc
Add nodeevents.DB to satellite overlay service so we can insert node
events into the nodeevents DB.
Change-Id: I642c0ccc9941ecdb08cb22d5c8cf701959a55156
We want to send emails to SNOs. Node status changes go through the
overlay service, so it's a good place to add the mail service.
Add the mailservice.Service, satellite address, and satellite name to
overlay service. Also add feature flag --overlay.send-node-emails
Change-Id: I3bd2cb3bf22f9724954ce2374f8b651b902b3a24
It looks that monikt monitoring can give high CPU overhead for
segments loop observer. With this code we are changing how monitoring
is initialized for observer methods. This optimization affects mainly
path where segment is healthy and doesn't require repair. Benchmark
is also added to show difference between old and new approach.
Benchmark against 'main':
name old time/op new time/op delta
RemoteSegment/Cockroach/healthy_segment-8 8.55µs ± 4% 1.37µs ± 6% -84.03% (p=0.008 n=5+5)
name old alloc/op new alloc/op delta
RemoteSegment/Cockroach/healthy_segment-8 2.63kB ± 0% 0.17kB ± 0% -93.62% (p=0.008 n=5+5)
name old allocs/op new allocs/op delta
RemoteSegment/Cockroach/healthy_segment-8 54.0 ± 0% 8.0 ± 0% -85.19% (p=0.008 n=5+5)
Change-Id: Ie138eab0d59e436395b13f57bdfb11f9871d4c18
We have an alert on `repair_too_many_nodes_failed` which fires too
frequently. Every time so far, it has been because of a network blip of
some nature on the satellite side.
Satellite operators are expected to have other means in place for
alerting on network problems and fixing them, so it's not necessary for
the repair framework to act in that way.
Instead, in this change, we change the way that
`repair_too_many_nodes_failed` works. When a repair fails, we collect
piece fetch errors by type and determine from them whether it looks like
we are having network problems (most errors are connection failures,
possibly also some successful connections which subsequently time out)
or whether something else has happened.
We will now only emit `repair_too_many_nodes_failed` when the outcome
does not look like a network failure. In the network failure case, we
will instead emit `repair_suspected_network_problem`.
Refs: https://github.com/storj/storj/issues/4669
Change-Id: I49df98da5df9c606b95ad08a2bdfec8092fba926
This structure is entirely unused within the audit module, and is only
used by repair code. Accordingly, this change moves the structure from
audit code to repair code.
Also, we take the opportunity here to rename the structure to something
less generic.
Refs: https://github.com/storj/storj/issues/4669
Change-Id: If85b37e08620cda1fde2afe98206293e02b5c36e
This is in response to community feedback that our existing reputation
calculation is too likely to disqualify storage nodes unfairly with
extreme swings up and down.
For details and analysis, please see the data_loss_vs_dq_chance_sim.py
tool, the "tuning reputation further.ipynb" Jupyter notebook in the
storj/datascience repository, and the discussion at
https://forum.storj.io/t/tuning-audit-scoring/14084
In brief: changing the lambda and initial-alpha parameters in this way
causes the swings in reputation to be smaller and less likely to put a
node past the disqualification threshold unfairly.
Note: this change will cause a one-time reset of all (non-disqualified)
node reputations, because the new initial alpha value of 1000 is
dramatically different, and the disqualification threshold is going to
be much higher.
Change-Id: Id6dc4ba8fde1be3db4255b72282207bab5491ca3
I don't know why the go people thought this was a good idea, because
this automatic reformatting is bound to do the wrong thing sometimes,
which is very annoying. But I don't see a way to turn it off, so best to
get this change out of the way.
Change-Id: Ib5dbbca6a6f6fc944d76c9b511b8c904f796e4f3
We made optimization for segment loop observers to avoid
heavy monkit initialization on each call. It was applied to very
often executed methods. Unfortunately we used wrong monkit
method to track function times. Instead mon.Task we used
mon.Func().
https://github.com/spacemonkeygo/monkit#how-it-works
Change-Id: I9ca454dbd828c6b43ba09ca75c341991d2fd73a8
We retry a GET_REPAIR operation in one case, and one case only (as far
as I can determine): when we are trying to connect to a node using its
last known working IP and port combination rather than its supplied
hostname, and we think the operation failed the first time because of a
Dial failure.
However, logs collected from storage node operators along with logs
collected from satellites are strongly indicating that we are retrying
GET_REPAIR operations in some cases even when we succeeded in connecting
to the node the first time. This results in the node complaining loudly
about being given a duplicate order limit (as it should), whereupon the
satellite counts that as an unknown error and potentially penalizes the
node.
See discussion at
https://forum.storj.io/t/get-repair-error-used-serial-already-exists-in-store/17922/36
.
Investigation into this problem has revealed that
`!piecestore.CloseError.Has(err)` may not be the best way of determining
whether a problem occurred during Dial. In fact, it is probably
downright Wrong. Handling of errors on a stream is somewhat complicated,
but it would appear that there are several paths by which an RPC error
originating on the remote side might show up during the Close() call,
and would thus be labeled as a "CloseError".
This change creates a new error class, repairer.ErrDialFailed, with
which we will now wrap errors that _really definitely_ occurred during
a Dial call. We will use this class to determine whether or not to retry
a GET_REPAIR operation. The error will still also be wrapped with
whatever wrapper classes it used to be wrapped with, so the potential
for breakage here should be minimal.
Refs: https://github.com/storj/storj/issues/4687
Change-Id: Ifdd3deadc8258f34cf3fbc42aff393fa545794eb
Recently we applied this optimization to metrics observer and time
used by its method dropped from 12m to 3m for us1 (220m segments).
It looks that it make sense to apply the same code to all observers.
Change-Id: I05898aaacbd9bcdf21babc7be9955da1db57bdf2
Implement a buffer for inserting repair items into the queue in a batch.
Part of https://github.com/storj/storj/issues/4727
Change-Id: I718472b2f2b1f4993c3d6f15c44923776407155a
TestSegmentInExcludedCountriesRepair and TestSegmentInExcludedCountriesRepairIrreparable are using 20 storage nodes.
This change make them use 7 by adjusting the test redundancy scheme.
Change-Id: I1a44aa8b997d6edcc9a3305fdd0dac57e4d525b5
To save load on DNS servers, the repair code first tries to dial the
last known good ip and port for a node, and then falls back to a DNS
lookup only if we fail to connect to the last known good ip and port.
However, it looks like we are seeing errors during the client stream
Close() call (probably due to quic-go code), and those are classified
the same as errors encountered during Dial. The repairer code sees this
error, assumes that we failed to contact the node, and retries- but
since we did actually succeed in connecting the first time around, this
results in submitting the same order limit (with the same serial number)
to the storage node, which (rightfully) rejects it.
So together with change I055c186d5fd4e79560f67763175bc3130b9bc7d2 in
storj/uplink, this should avoid the double submission and avoid dinging
nodes' suspension scores unfairly.
See https://github.com/storj/storj/issues/4687.
Also, moving the testsuite directory check up above check-monkit in the
Jenkins Lint task, so that a non-tidy testsuite/go.mod can be recognized
and handled before everything breaks weirdly and seemingly randomly
later on.
Change-Id: Icb2b05aaff921d0af6aba10e450ac7e0a7bb2655
We don't need to have every single test for both, only one for
each should be sufficient. For all other tests it doesn't matter
which one we use.
Change-Id: I9962206a4ee025d367332c29ea3e6bc9f0f9a1de
For nodes in excluded areas, we don't necessarily want to remove them
from the pointer, but we do want to increase the number of pieces in the
segment in case those excluded area nodes go down. To do that, we
increase the number of pieces repaired by the number of pieces in
excluded areas.
Change-Id: I0424f1bcd7e93f33eb3eeeec79dbada3b3ea1f3a
Add a RepairExcludedCountryCodes config flag for overlay for providing a list of country codes to exclude nodes from target repair selection.
Mark segments with less than repairThreshold pieces in countries not in the RepairExcludedCountryCodes as not healthy.
With this change, the repair process is not affected. The segment will be removed from the repair queue by the repairer.
Another change will handle the logic at the repairer level.
Fixes https://github.com/storj/team-metainfo/issues/95
Change-Id: I9231b32de117a116488de055a3e94efcabb46e81
The "satellite fetch-pieces" command allows a satellite operator to
fetch as many pieces of a segment as possible, along with their
original order limits and hashes as provided by the storage nodes. The
fetched pieces and associated info will be stored on in a specified
folder as they are, rather than being RS-decoded or decrypted.
It is hoped that this will allow easier debugging of certain one-off
problems we've observed in the wild.
Change-Id: I42ae0e9ef0023538e42473a9be5a2460a3ac0f3a
inconsistency
The original design had a flaw which can potentially cause discrepancy
for nodes reputation status between reputations table and nodes table.
In the event of a failure(network issue, db failure, satellite failure, etc.)
happens between update to reputations table and update to nodes table, data
can be out of sync.
This PR tries to fix above issue by passing through node's reputation from
the beginning of an audit/repair(this data is from nodes table) to the next
update in reputation service. If the updated reputation status from the service
is different from the existing node status, the service will try to update nodes
table. In the case of a failure, the service will be able to try update nodes
table again since it can see the discrepancy of the data. This will allow
both tables to be in-sync eventually.
Change-Id: Ic22130b4503a594b7177237b18f7e68305c2f122
If satellite can't find enough nodes to successfully download a segment,
it probably is not the fault of storage nodes.
Change-Id: I681f66056df0bb940da9edb3a7dbb3658c0a56cb
work
Since we have changed the repair worker to also mark a node as audit
failure if they return a not found error, we should ignore expired
segments when possible
Change-Id: Ie6a677e1d7b234e93965c736d05950440236653c
This change introduce problems with server side move so
let's revert it for now. Problem was found when latest
version of storj/storj was used in uplink tests.
This reverts commit 1ef06fae99.
Change-Id: I4d4fad5d1ea04ba15ff9d7bd765f7e078e9187c2
We were using mixed types for nonce fields. Protobuf
have storj.Nonce, metabase have []byte. This change
is a refactoring to have everywere its possible only
storj.Nonce.
Change-Id: Id54bd8481f30c721cdaf3df79206d25e7cfdab55
Update repair tests to check if audit score increases for nodes
that successfully send pieces during successfull and failed repairs.
Change-Id: Ie6abbde6155ab4697d209366c9fa497e731756e9
At some point we moved metabase package outside Metainfo
but we didn't do that for satellite structure. This change
refactors only tests.
When uplink will be adjusted we can remove old entries in
Metainfo struct.
Change-Id: I2b66ed29f539b0ec0f490cad42c72840e0351bcb
When we can't complete an audit or repair, we need more information about
what happened during each individual share/piece download.
In audit, add the number of offline, unknown, contained, failed nodes to
the error log. In repair, combine the errors from each download and add
them to the error log.
Change-Id: Ic5d2a0f3f291f26cb82662bfb37355dd2b5c89ba
This change adds a NOT NULL constraint to the created_at column in the segment table.
All occurrences of CreatedAt as a pointer are changed to non pointer version (metabase, segment loop, etc)
Change-Id: I3efd476ebd1edd3327b69c9223d9edc800e1cc52
This change adds dedicated methods on metabase.Pieces to be able to add, remove pieces and also to check duplicates.
Change-Id: I21aaeff40c017c2ebe1cc85a864ae546754769cc
Error from joining loop should not restart satellite. This will be the
same error like for loop itself. In the same way we are handling joining
error for other services that are using segment loop.
Change-Id: Idf1035ef7f78462927bd23989ed8a4ee5826c49e
Sometimes we see timeouts from DNS lookups when trying to do
repair GETs. Solution: try using node's last IP and port first.
If we can't connect, retry with DNS lookup.
Change-Id: I59e223aebb436118779fb18378f6e09d072f12be
We want to use StreamID/Position to identify injured
segment. As it is hard to alter existing injuredsegments
table we are adding a new table that will replace existing
one. Old table will be dropped later.
Change-Id: I0d3b06522645013178b6678c19378ebafe485c49
This is part of metaloop refactoring. We plan to remove
irreparable at some point but there was not time for it.
Now instead refatoring it for segmentloop its just easier
to drop it.
Later we still need to drop table with migration step.
Change-Id: I270e77f119273d39a1ecdcf5e1c37a5662a29ab4
Satellites set their configuration values to default values using
cfgstruct, however, it turns out our tests don't test these values
at all! Instead, they have a completely separate definition system
that is easy to forget about.
As is to be expected, these values have drifted, and it appears
in a few cases test planet is testing unreasonable values that we
won't see in production, or perhaps worse, features enabled in
production were missed and weren't enabled in testplanet.
This change makes it so all values are configured the same,
systematic way, so it's easy to see when test values are different
than dev values or release values, and it's less hard to forget
to enable features in testplanet.
In terms of reviewing, this change should be actually fairly
easy to review, considering private/testplanet/satellite.go keeps
the current config system and the new one and confirms that they
result in identical configurations, so you can be certain that
nothing was missed and the config is all correct.
You can also check the config lock to see what actual config
values changed.
Change-Id: I6715d0794887f577e21742afcf56fd2b9d12170e
Piece hash verification failures during repair download are considered
audit failures, but we are not logging these occurrences. Now we log
them.
Change-Id: If456cebcfda6af7a659be3d1fc74448e681fb653
Currently the interface is not useful. When we need to vary the
implementation for testing purposes we can introduce a local interface
for the service/chore that needs it, rather than using the large api.
Unfortunately, this requires adding a cleanup callback for tests, there
might be a better solution to this problem.
Change-Id: I079fe4dbe297b0ae08c10081a1cea4dfbc277682
errs.Class should not contain "error" in the name, since that causes a
lot of stutter in the error logs. As an example a log line could end up
looking like:
ERROR node stats service error: satellitedbs error: node stats database error: no rows
Whereas something like:
ERROR nodestats service: satellitedbs: nodestatsdb: no rows
Would contain all the necessary information without the stutter.
Change-Id: I7b7cb7e592ebab4bcfadc1eef11122584d2b20e0
Initially we duplicated the code to avoid large scale changes to
the packages. Now we are past metainfo refactor we can remove the
duplication.
Change-Id: I9d0b2756cc6e2a2f4d576afa408a15273a7e1cef
Currently the loop handling is heavily related to the metabase rather
than metainfo.
metainfo over time has become related to the "public API" for accessing
the metabase data.
Currently updates monkit.lock, because monkit monitoring does not handle
ScopeNamed correctly. Needs a followup change to monitoring check.
Change-Id: Ie50519991d718dfb872ec9a0176a82e732c97584
metabase has become a central concept and it's more suitable for it to
be directly nested under satellite rather than being part of metainfo.
metainfo is going to be the "endpoint" logic for handling requests.
Change-Id: I53770d6761ac1e9a1283b5aa68f471b21e784198
Check that the bloom filter creation date is earlier than the
metainfo loop system time used for db scanning.
Change-Id: Ib0f47c124f5651deae0fd7e7996abcdcaac98fb4
Repair checker expects to have information about CreatedAt and RepairedAt fields to calculate segment age metric.
Change-Id: I6b41df880d77133be541e14d10d91cc75759b339
At some point we might try to change original segment RS values and set Pieces according to the new values. This change adds add NewRedundancy parameter for UpdateSegmentPieces method to give ability to do that. As a part of change NewPieces are validated against NewRedundancy.
Change-Id: I8ea531c9060b5cd283d3bf4f6e4c320099dd5576
We have multipart objects so we may get multiple inline segments
sequences or no segments at all for objects.
Change-Id: Ie46ee777a2db8f18f7154e3443bb9e07ecb170f7
It's impossible to time correctly this check. The segment may expire
just at the time we upload the repaired pieces to new storage nodes.
They will reject this as expired and the repair will fail.
Also, we penalize storage nodes with audit failure only if they fail
piece hash verification, i.e. return incorrect data, but only if they
have already deleted the piece.
So, it would be best if the repair service does not care about object
expiration at all. This is a responsibility of another service.
Removing this check will also simplify how we migrate this code
correctly to the metabase.
Change-Id: I09f7b372ae2602daee919a8a73cd0475fb263cd2
Do not insert the number of healthy pieces for segment health anymore.
Rather, insert the segment health calculated by our new priority
function.
Change-Id: Ieee7fb2deee89f4d79ae85bac7f577befa2a0c7f
