Handling of the string length condition in should_update
was broken, as evident with the log message
> leaving systemd-boot 246 in place (250.4 is not newer)
Discussion with @mweinelt came to the conclusion
that Python's "<" operator already does what we need,
so the should_update function can be dropped.
Fixes a30de3b849
Since, 4ddc78818e systemd-boot-builder
is broken in two ways:
* if no systemd-boot is currently installed *and* the NIXOS_INSTALL_BOOTLOADER
env variable is not set, it will try to run "bootctl update", which will fail
* if the currently installed systemd-boot version is newer than the version
we're about to install, it will also try to run "bootctl update", which will fail
This patch changes the behaviour,
* for the first case to still fail, but not even bother to try running
"bootctl update" and instead erroring out with an exception
* for the second case to leave the newer version in place, restoring
the pre - 4ddc78818e behaviour
To do the proper version check a new "should_update" helper function was introduced,
mimicing the compare_product C function from bootctl. If the following systemd
issue gets resolved, we would have a nice way to get rid of this function:
> https://github.com/systemd/systemd/issues/23450
This change allows to again switch to a different NixOS configuration which contains
an older systemd-boot.
Co-authored-by: Martin Weinelt <mweinelt@users.noreply.github.com>
`extra-utils` composes the set of programs and libraries needed by
1. copying over all programs
2. copying over all libraries any program directly links against
3. set the runtime path for every program to the library directory
It seems that this approach misses the case where a library itself links
against another library. That is to say, `extra-utils` assumes that
either only progams link against libraries or that every library linked
to by a library is already linked to by a program.
`mount.zfs` linking against `libcrypto`, in turn linking against `libdl`
shows how the current approach falls short:
```
$ objdump -p $(which mount.zfs) | grep NEEDED | grep -e libdl -e libcrypto
NEEDED libcrypto.so.1.1
$ ldd (which mount.zfs) | grep libdl
libdl.so.2 => /nix/store/ybkkrhdwdj227kr20vk8qnzqnmj7a06x-glibc-2.34-115/lib/libdl.so.2 (0x00007f9967a9a000
```
Using `mount.zfs` directly in stage 1 init still works since
`LD_LIBRARY_PATH` overrides this (as intended).
util-linux's `mount` however executes `mount.zfs` with LD_LIBRARY_PATH
removed from its environment as can be seen with strace(1) in an
interactive stage 1 init shell (`boot.shell_on_fail` kernel parameter):
```
# env -i LD_LIBRARY_PATH=$LD_LIBRARY_PATH $(which strace) -ff -e trace=/exec -v -qqq $(which mount) /mnt-root
execve("/nix/store/3gqbb3swgiy749fxd5a4k6kirkr2jr9n-extra-utils/bin/mount", ["/nix/store/3gqbb3swgiy749fxd5a4k"..., "/mnt-root"], ["LD_LIBRARY_PATH=/nix/store/3gqbb"...]) = 0
[pid 1026] execve("/sbin/mount.zfs", ["/sbin/mount.zfs", "<redacted>", "/mnt-root", "-o", "rw,zfsutil"], []) = 0
/sbin/mount.zfs: error while loading shared libraries: libdl.so.2: cannot open shared object file: No such file or directory
--- SIGCHLD {si_signo=SIGCHLD, si_code=CLD_EXITED, si_pid=1026, si_uid=0, si_status=127, si_utime=0, si_stime=0} ---
```
env(1) is used for clarity (hence subshells for absoloute paths).
While `mount` uses the right library path, `mount.zfs` is stripped of
it, so ld.so(8) fails resolve `libdl` (as required by `libcrypto`).
To fix this and not rely on `LD_LIBRARY_PATH` to be set, fix the library
path inside libraries as well.
This finally mounts all ZFS filesystems using `zfsutil` with correct and
intended mount options.
At least pkgs/os-specific/linux/util-linux/default.nix uses
```
"--enable-fs-paths-default=/run/wrappers/bin:/run/current-system/sw/bin:/sbin"
```
which does not cover stage 1 init's PATH as all executables are put
under /bin/.
Fix util-linux's `mount` usage by symlinking /sbin to it.
Consider ZFS filesystems meant to be mounted with zfs.mount(8), e.g.
```
config.fileSystems."/media".options = [ "zfsutil" ];
config.fileSystems."/nix".options = [ "zfsutil" ];
```
`zfsutil` uses dataset properties as mount options such that zfsprops(7)
do not have to be duplicated in fstab(5) entries or manual mount(8)
invocations.
Given the example configuation above, /media is correctly mounted with
`setuid=off` translated into `nosuid`:
```
$ zfs get -Ho value setuid /media
off
$ findmnt -t zfs -no options /media
rw,nosuid,nodev,noexec,noatime,xattr,posixacl
```
/nix however was mounted with default mount(8) options:
```
$ zfs get -Ho value setuid /nix
off
$ findmnt -t zfs -no options /nix
rw,relatime,xattr,noacl
```
This holds true for all other ZFS properties/mount options, including
`exec/[no]exec`, `devices/[no]dev`, `atime/[no]atime`, etc.
/nix is mounted using BusyBox's `mount` during stage 1 init while /media
is mounted later using proper systemd and/or util-linux's `mount`.
Tracing stage 1 init showed that BusyBox never tried to execute
mount.zfs(8) as intended by `zfsutil`.
Replacing it with util-linux's `mount` and adding the mount helper
showed attempts to execute mount.zfs(8).
Ensure ZFS filesystems are mounted with correct options iff `zfsutil` is
used.
Account for all `with*` options causing their respective unit files to
not be built, just like the current code `withCryptsetup` already does.
This fixes build errors like the following:
```
missing /nix/store/5fafsfms64fn3ywv274ky7arhm9yq2if-systemd-250.4/example/systemd/system/systemd-importd.service
error: builder for '/nix/store/67rdli5q5akzwmqgf8q0a1yp76jgr0px-system-units.drv' failed with exit code 1
```
Found by using a customised systemd package as follows:
```
systemd.package = pkgs.systemd-small;
nixpkgs.config.packageOverrides = pkgs: {
"systemd-small" = pkgs.systemd.override {
withImportd = false;
withMachined = false;
...
};
};
```
These two packages don't have a lib/firmware directory, so putting
them in hardware.firmware has no effect. This will become a hard
error once firmware compression is implemented.
(In the case of Linux, the firmware was all moved to linux-firmware.)
This special case for Btrfs was added in 51bc82960a. One year later beddd36c95 added code to skip the fsck entirely if the filesystem is Btrfs. This made the `if` statement unnecessary.
People running nixos-install in non-NixOS environments
occasionally run into the mktemp builtin not being loaded
into bash (yes, even NixOS' bash). Rather than try and
figure out why exactly that is happening, just use a known
good mktemp from coreutils.
We can make the growfs and makefs binaries conditional because we know
if we'll need them. Also move the cryptsetup generator to the luksroot
so it's not included when not needed.
We drop some generators altogether: systemd-getty-generator because we
don't have getty anyway in stage 1, systemd-system-update-generator
because we don't use that logic in NixOS and
systemd-veritysetup-generator because stage 1 has no veritysetup support
(yet) and if it had, we still wouldn't want to include the generator
unconditionally.
